That’s how an excellent article in this week’s Spectator describes the way Western countries are attempting to limit the growth of developing nations such as China and India, on the pretext of limiting greenhouse gas emissions.
On 27 September, George Bush - a man who has consistently opposed all attempts to get US emissions reduced - will host a conference in Washington at which he is widely expected to call for the imposition of cuts in emissions in developing nations.
His call will ignore three key facts:
* Emissions per head of population in developing nations are way below those of developed countries.
* Large chunks of their emissions are due to the fact that they are now producing goods for the West. We’ve effectively shifted our own manufacturing abroad, because it saves us money.
* We have no right to demand that foreigners continue to live in poverty. We had our industrial revolution; now they are having theirs.
The original Kyoto treaty - from which Bush withdrew - exempted developing nations for these very reasons.
As the Spectator article points out, since 1997, Western efforts to cut carbon emissions have come to almost naught. US carbon emissions are now 15% higher than they were in 1990 - the baseline used for all Kyoto targets. Japan’s emissions have risen by 11%. While EU carbon emissions have fallen by 2.9%, overall greenhouse gas emissions have risen.
In spite of this record of non-achievement, the West is increasingly hectoring the developing world on its carbon emissions.
But look at the facts:
Per head of population, in 2003 the Chinese emitted 3.2 tonnes of carbon and India 1.9 tonnes. The US, on the other hand, emitted 19.8 tonnes of carbon per capita. The UK emitted 9.4 tonnes, Germany 9.8 tonnes and France 6.4 tonnes. And, of course, these figures would have been even higher, had we not outsourced much of our manufacturing to countries such as China.
I’d encorage you to read the Spectator article. It’s an illuminating and somewhat depressing piece of journalism that points out the utter hypocrisy of Western governments.
Filed by Trevor at August 15th, 2007 under
Blog,
Climate Change,
Carbon Reduction |
No comments